This essay is aimed at western Marxists wholly and the debate circles we find ourselves in

Wellesley - October 25 Marks the 100th Anniversary of the Russian…

A specter is haunting the modern-day Communist movement: the specter of…the Russian Revolution?

The Russian Revolution was a world-historic event that ushered humanity into a new age. Whether one is a Trot, ‘Stalinist’, anarchist, left communist, etc., almost all major socialist ideologies saw their side temporarily win and then be defeated in the course of the Russian Revolution and subsequent experiment. Whether it was the hostile takeover of the Soviets that ended the Revolution, the crushing of the Makhnovshchina, the rise of Stalin to power and the adoption of socialism in one country, the rise of Khrushchev, or the subsequent end of the Soviet Union by Gorbachev, almost every ideology got to play ball and get called out.

However, 30 years after the fall of the USSR, the modern-day left has a problem. It’s still stuck in debates from 1917 that are no longer relevant!

Take the Trotsky/Stalin split for example. The crux of the Trotsky/Stalin split was the question of the Russian peasantry. Were the Russian peasantry revolutionary enough for Russia to move forward, or did Russia need to expand its Revolution to Western Europe before it proceeded to a higher stage? Trotsky took the first stance. Stalin proposed that since Russia was isolated and surrounded by hostile powers, they go ahead and proceed without Europe and the world, then aid other revolutions until the final victory of socialism was realized. This debate still rages on today. Trotskyists see Stalin’s fingers everywhere they go, in places that don’t even nominally resemble Stalin. Marxist-Leninists argue about the efficacy of Socialism in one country. However, there is one big problem regarding this debate. PEASANTS DON’T EXIST ANYMORE, THERE ARE NO MORE PEASANTS, THE DEBATE IS ALMOST COMPLETELY ANTIQUATED!

Serfdom - Wikipedia

The fact of the matter is semi-feudal Russia was the worst place possible for a proletariat revolution to happen. Socialist revolution, as Marx envisioned, needed to be global and occur in the most highly developed economies (though he did later see something in Russia’s peasant communes). Semi-feudal Russia was underdeveloped and completely economically isolated and hostilely so (invaded by 13 nations, later invaded by the Nazis). Spreading its Revolution would have been a death sentence. Ultimately the path taken by Stalin was the most pragmatic at that time for the fledgling experiment. However…

The political shell that the USSR took on for its survival, synthesized by Stalin, I believe has limited the imaginations of many Marxist-Leninists about what future proletarian revolutions must look like. Firstly, socialism in one country made sense for Russia at that time under its conditions (the worst possible basically), but in future revolutions that occur within especially the ‘first world’, we must push for them to become international. We are no longer in semi-feudal Russia. And while the political shell synthesized by Stalin might still be necessary for revolutions that break out within the global south without spreading to surrounding countries or globally (especially when the American B-2 bombers start flying overhead), we must fight for a vision of socialist revolutions as inherently international!

Secondly, regarding Stalin, we have to put him under some self-critique. His failures to send support to international revolutions when they really needed the USSR’s support (Greece, support for Israel, and the Korean War especially) are dark marks on his legacy.

Thirdly, the USSR was forced to limit its direct democracy due to internal sabotage by kulaks, external threats of war; overall it was a siege society. We must envision future socialisms as inherently much more democratic, with, as Marx envisioned, direct recall for all serving within administrative roles of the dictatorship of the proletariat and a new apparatus that wholly smashes the old state. Marx also envisioned the dictatorship of the proletariat as an apparatus that was in the process of withering away upon its foundation. Again, if revolution breaks out in the global south and it does not spread or become global, they may not be able to implement this due to the CIA and will have to follow the old Stalin-derived method in order to hold out until a world revolution comes from American/imperialist shenanigans. Which is completely understandable, but you can already see how we are setting ourselves self-imposed limits before these events even occur.

And finally, the ability to imagine an end to class society, the state, and commodity production relatively quickly by the time revolution comes to the ‘imperial core’. (And of course, if these are not possible immediately or relatively quickly then we will see how they play out according to the conditions at the time.) These I find are all lacking within my fellow Western Marxist-Leninists who I feel as though are still stuck within a ‘siege’ mentality when our highly industrialized and globalized societies that are at the centers of world capitalism are nothing like semi-feudal Russia in 1917. And these self-imposed limits hinder our imaginations of even future revolutions in the global south! What if a revolution breaks out that spreads and is able to transcend the limitations placed on Russia? That could very well happen!

The ‘lessons’ learned from the Russian Revolution present their own bag of worms. Some communists have taken the lesson from the Russian Revolution’s failure that all parliamentarism is a road to bureaucratic failure (Marx argued we should organize in parliaments strategically). The party form is inherently corrupt and reproduces capitalist relations (Marx organized in parties that led the working class, such as the Communist League), etc. These people in response to the failures of the Russian experiment have revised some important aspects of Marx himself which he advocated for as a historical materialist they’ve become more Marxist than Marx I suppose (don’t laugh).

Marx and Engels on electoralism and 'lesser evil' voting. : r/socialism

The Communists, therefore, are on the one hand, practically, the most advanced and resolute section of the working-class parties of every country, that section which pushes forward all others; on the other hand, theoretically, they have over the great mass of the proletariat the advantage of clearly understanding the line of march, the conditions, and the ultimate general results of the proletarian movement.

— Karl Marx, The Communist Manifesto, Chapter 2

And fundamentally distortion and abstraction of of Marxism cannot overcome the tendency of the labor movements and spontaneity’s affinity for reformism rather than finishing the job of overthrowing capitalism, localism (being unable to expand since they’re horizontally organized), and bourgeois ideas infiltrating the workers movement without an organized party to stop such things. And failure after failure of spontaneous uprisings has proved such a thing to be impossible (The Gwangju Uprising 1980, May 1968 France, The Sessantotto 1968, ect). The Russian Revolution weighs on these people in a complete over-correction of Marxist materialism and drift into utopian socialist tendencies.

Trotskyists themselves focus on calling for the overthrow of all Marxist-Leninist governments, which I’m sure if they succeeded in the best-case scenarios would solve some issues (particularly corruption, bureaucrats), but would not address the biggest issue. These states cannot dissolve themselves or achieve socialism until capitalism is ended on a world scale. And changing their governments would only change who fights and eventually gets boxed in by American B-2s. (Though China, I would argue, does have the industrial base to become more aggressive if it wanted to spread socialist revolution, but it’s up to the Chinese people not us).

It appears as though Trotskyists’ minds still remain within 1917, just as the Marxist-Leninists’ do, just as much as the non-party-form Marxists do, debating within the Politburo or 1917 Western Europe which course the fresh experiment should take when neither Politburo nor the conditions that created that nation exist any longer.

Those that claim that the USSR was state capitalist present their own circus. The Maoists that claim it was under Khrushchev fight with the Trotskyists who follow Tony Cliff who argue that the USSR was state capitalist under Stalin, who then fight with the Bordigists who argue the USSR was always state capitalist but Lenin admitted so, who then fight with the council communists who believe that the organic centralist structure of the Bordigists reproduces capitalism… and on and on the game goes.

These men seem to be under the ghost of the Russian Revolution in their own way. What on earth would the average person looking into these debate circles about whether a long-dead experiment was this form or that form of state capitalist think? Certainly Marxism is a ruthless criticism of all that exists, but the USSR no longer exists. And yet it can generate more arguments and essays than a simple question such as: What should we do next? This is not me calling for anti-intellectualism (in fact, I find many of their critiques particularly around the retention of the commodity form fair), but rather a question of what the fuck are we doing with our time. Is this really the most productive way to spend our time in the 21st century when we could be analyzing what our next steps could be?

Flintstones | Tom and jerry cartoon, Tom and jerry, Tom and jerry pictures

Ultimately, we can and must be both-minded. We can accept the great accomplishments and lessons learned from the Russian Revolution and its ultimate demise while not being weighed down by its limitations within the present. We must not allow utopian socialist distortions of Marxist pedagogy to enter the movement just because the USSR failed. I urge my comrades to imagine a world beyond what the Soviets were ever able to achieve or even imagine, not be stuck in the debate halls of 1917 arguing whether the acquisition of 200 hectares of grain from the peasants in Volga would have saved the Russian Revolution. Learn from the past, maintain your materialism, but do not be held by the ghost of the Russian Revolution. Rather, exercise your Marxism in the present.

To put it another way, the Communist movement around the globe is the spirit, the objective conditions of capitalism and how to achieve socialism the subject. The spirit has managed, through the Russian Revolution, to get to the first step of the process in understanding the subject: categorization. However, these categories, as much as they are stepping stones to a higher understanding, themselves can quickly become a prison. The categories that we carry from the lessons of the USSR cannot weigh us down. And they must become organic and ever-changing with the subject to understand it on a higher plane. The Russian Revolution is a stepping stone to our understanding of how to carry out a socialist revolution, not an island to get stuck on.

A brief history of the world communist movement – Communist Party USA

And of course, to me, everyone who is genuine about revolution is a comrade no matter how much we debate, whether they believe in the party form or not, whether they ‘like’ Stalin or the USSR or not. Those who are genuine to the overthrow of capitalism have a seat at my table and my revolutionary praxis. I will work with anyone who is not a grifter, a revisionist, or who moves like an ‘op’ (prefers personal attacks over theoretical disputes).

Leave a Reply

Trending